Sunday, October 19, 2008

Lucy is real

I feel like I've met Sandra Cisneros. That's the kind of writer she is: reading her books is like reading an extension of her life. I start to wonder, "Did she actually have a friend named Lucy who smelled like corn? Did she hear that story from a friend? Was it all from her imagination?" And finally, I ask myself: "Does it matter?" The writing is just that good.

It was interesting how the book was sectioned into three stages of life: childhood, adolescence, and adulthood. My favorite story from the childhood section has to be 'Eleven'. I've actually taken to reading the first few paragraphs of this story to friends and family because I love it that much! As I read it to them, I notice small smiles appearing around the corners of their lips, and I know that this story is affecting them the same as it did's bringing them back. Yah, sometimes I feel like I'm three and sometimes I feel like I'm twenty-three, but it's funny to think that I am every age in between. And it's true that I don't feel my age until about half way through that year. It really has to grow on you first, until you are almost the next year. The ideas of Cisneros blow me's stuff you don't think about, but you know is a Seinfeld show.

I was shocked by the stories in the short adolescent section. The ideas aren't knew to me, but let's just say I didn't see them coming. The same with the adult section...I just wanted to reach into the book and shake some sense into these characters!!! What was interesting was that these protagonists are all chicanas, but their stories are so universal that you can apply them to anyone. Cisnero's brings the experiences to life. To me, Lucy is real.

I'm curious about how this book affected the guys in our class. It is really harsh with some of its male stereotypes and it's all for women making a better life for themselves (although it's rare when the characters actually do!) Did you men in the class feel the same way that I felt about the book?


Kaan said...

Hey Katie,

I find it so interesting that you feel like you almost personally got to know Sandra Cisneros through her readings. I guess I could say that I kind of felt that way, although I also feel like she her personality is all across the board! I mean, she seems to go in so many directions with her thoughts and beliefs. I should also probably take into consideration that you read the entire novel and I'm only half way through. But anyway...

As for your comment on "Eleven" I definitely agree about being able to relate to her stories, and about being that age. It kind of "brings you back" in a sense to what things are like at the age for children. Cisneros clearly wants to make a strong connection with the reader in order to link her own personal experiences with your own.

Overall, I'm slightly excited to finish it, but definitely not super into it. Great observations as always!


Jacqui said...

Hey Katie,

I love your enthusiasm with this book, and I LOVE the connection you made to the Seinfeld's totally true; Cisneros is able to bring so many different ideas to the forefront of her stories..ideas and description that we often don't realise but know are as you said a Seinfeld it!